Back to Manuscript
 
  Table 1. Performance data based on student responses.

                              Use of Nucleophile / Electrophile Reaction Guide
in and out
in class
out of class
any use
none
of class
only
only
(wt. ave.
(control)
(YY)
(YN)
(NY)
YY, YN, NY)
(NN)
Count
21
25
17
63
63
GPA
3.23
3.38
3.38
  
3.25
CUAT score
66.1
69.8
62.8
66.4
66.8
control score -
0.7
-3.0
4.0
0.4
0.0
group score
% correct
Q1
66.7
76.0
70.6
71.4
66.7
Q2
85.7
84.0
82.4
84.1
80.9
Q3
57.1
80.0
82.4
73.0
68.3
Q4
52.4
52.0
52.9
52.4
42.9
Q5
90.5
76.0
76.5
81.0
61.9
corrected Ave Q1-Q5
70.5
73.6
73.0
72.4
64.1
corrected Ave Q1-Q5
71.2
70.6
77.0
72.8
64.1