Chemical Education Journal (CEJ), Vol. 5, No. 2 /Registration No. 5-26/Received September 4, 2001.
URL = http://www.juen.ac.jp/scien/cssj/cejrnlE.html

Computer-assisted Instruction in Chemistry

L. Glasser

Molecular Science Institute, Department of Chemistry, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa

E-mail: glasser@aurum.wits.ac.za

Abstract: The Department of Chemistry at the University of the Witwatersrand has been developing and using a computer-assisted instructional (CAI) system for its first-year students since 1980. The programs were initially developed for the Apple II microcomputer, but have been adapted, extended and enhanced for the PC (initially for the MS-DOS operating system, but now usable under Windows) since about 1995. The programs have an integrated marks management system which can be interrogated by both students and supervisors. There are presently about 90 programs in use, accessed by all students in our first-year classes; thus, the system is used well in excess of 10,000 times annually. The programs are of a 'practice-and-guidance' type, supporting the lecturers and tutors through assistance to students in the learning of routine procedures and providing encouraging advice when encountering student error. The system is well-established, with copies in operation at a number of tertiary institutions in South Africa, and a selection of six published by the Journal of Chemical Education. A sub-set of the programs would be suitable for school use, and have been adapted for this purpose. The presentation will cover the process of development of the material, addressing issues of quality and reliability, and its application in student learning.

 

Introduction and brief history

The University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, is a major university within Africa, with high scholarly and academic aspirations. The degrees that it awards are internationally recognised and accredited, yet it exists in an environment of excessively poor schooling for much of its student intake.
  The Department of Chemistry has been involved in the development of computer-assisted instruction (CAI) in Chemistry since 1980, when the first six Apple II microcomputers were purchased for the Department. At that time, we in the Department had become increasingly conscious of the desperate educational needs of the increasing numbers of disadvantaged students entering the University, and were initiating a 'slow-stream' Chemistry course, including enhanced tutorial support, to better serve the needs of such students. However, we were also aware of our limited resource of funding and experienced tutors. We therefore determined to support that resource by supplying CAI as an additional tutorial mechanism which, hopefully, would reduce the burden on our tutors. 
The initial intention was to supply commercial programs, which were then starting to become available, for use by students. However, those first programs were so rudimentary, so poor in instruction and in display (lacking lower-case letters, sub- and superscripts, and - of course - special characters) that an immediate decision was taken to prepare our own material in such a way as to have standard chemical appearance. We also decided to incorporate an extensive marks record system, for keeping track of student progress in the use of the programs. 
This decision was implemented by employing students as programmers, either adapting the commercial programs to our own requirements or developing our own. This proved a largely successful venture, with these students being keen and resourceful programmers. However, they were not so keen on accuracy, reliability, consistency and uniformity of screen appearance - on all of which we insisted for the ease of users who are unsophisticated in computing or even keyboarding. To ease and standardize this process, we built up a library of standard modules for matters like keyboard input, screen output, special characters, marks recording, and the like. A special feature is the input of chemical formulae by means of a 'cellular automaton' which converts simple keyboard entry to upper- or lower-case, superscript or subscript, according to its 'knowledge' of chemical formula display. Access to the programs is menu-driven.

 
Use of the CAI programs, and their wider distribution

The CAI programs were implemented from 1981, with users showing a keen interest in the programs, not only for sessional 'practice-and-guidance' but also for revision.
 

Within a few years, we had developed a set of useful programs which were in constant use by students. The use of these programs was reported in various fora and by publication of descriptive articles (see Bibliography). In due course we were approached by the publishers, NASOU, to translate a sub-set of our programs into Afrikaans for use in schools. We took the opportunity of the contract to revise our programs to a higher standard, as well as translating them. Unfortunately, NASOU seemed to abandon the project, and has never published the translated programs.
 

The newly-revised programs were so successful that we decided to undertake our own publishing, eventually selling (at a minimal price) about 50 sets to local schools, Technikons and Universities.
 

Our internal use of the programs continued over all this time, during which we installed a network for the Apple II's, which had grown to about 20 stations, with a 10Mb(!) hard drive as the central server. However, the Apple II's began to show their age after about 10 years in service (in terms of hardware failures, but also in screen appearance and versatility). Therefore, a process of conversion of the now-75 programs to QuickBASIC for PC's was undertaken, again with a set of enthusiastic programmers who provided innovative methods of screen display and control, marks recording, and so forth. The programs were implemented on the Chemistry PC network which had, in the meantime, been put in place in parallel with the Apple network.
 

Once the PC programs were fully operational, the Apple network was scrapped (and, in due course, donated to the Johannesburg College of Education). The PC network has, since that time, grown into a substantial system with about 100 workstations attached, about 30 of which are largely devoted to CAI. In many ways, the growth of our computer network has been driven by the demands of the CAI system, and even funded from the resources and interest generated by it (for example, by a grant of about one-quarter of a million Rand in 1997 from the New Settlers Foundation).
 

Since 1998, every first-year student has been required to demonstrate mastery (by obtaining a mark of greater than 79%) of a limited set of programs, as set out by the class co-ordinators. On the basis of a two-hourly count throughout 2 weeks, we have noted daily averages of about 100 first-year students using the CAI material - which implies much greater numbers throughout the day. We record roughly 15 000 program usages per annum.
 

The programs are pedagogically sound and, since the content of first-year chemistry is very stable, they remain valid and useful even many years after their initial programming - and will remain so for years to come. Although DOS-based, the programs run without problems in all Microsoft Windows environments since low-level device access is not implemented in the programs.  We are in the process of converting some of the programs to Microsoft's Visual BASIC (see Kinetic Approach to Equilibrium).
 


Marketing of the CAI programs

The revised programs are of such quality that a small sub-set of six has repeatedly been published by the Journal of Chemical Education: Software (1). We have also attempted to market the material in a number of ways; our most successful procedure has been by sending out a letter with a demonstration disk to local secondary and tertiary educational institutions. In this way, we have sold a few sets of the newest program material to schools, universities and technical institutions in South Africa.

A comprehensive Catalogue of the programs is available as well as an Installation and Teacher's Guide to the CAI system - which is worthwhile reading. These can be downloaded from http://www.chem.wits.ac.za.  A demonstration disk can be downloaded from the same site.

Recently, the Wits University Press has undertaken the marketing of the program material.


Conclusion

The CAI story in Chemistry is one of considerable success, developing from the initial small operation for tutorial assistance to a limited set of our first-year students, to one which provides welcome support across the board for all of our first-year students. We believe that it may be one of the largest single-Department efforts of this nature anywhere.

 

In addition to its value within the Department, our suite of programs has received considerable acceptance in other tertiary institutions in this country.

 
 
Reference

 

(1) J.D. Bradley, G. Brink, L. Glasser and P. van Zyl, Set of six CAI programs in Chemistry: Coulomb's Law, Electrochemistry, Solubility Product, Nuclear Chemistry, Colligative Properties, Periodic Table Trends, J. Chem. Educ: Software, 1996, 73, 323; 1996, vol. 9B(1); 1997, Special Vol. 16 on CD-ROM; 1998, 2nd ed.

 

Bibliography  

J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, Using Computers in Education, 1982, Spectrum, May, 62-4.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, The Microcomputer Revolution in Chemistry Teaching at Wits, 1983, Apple Education News, 1(1), 1.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, Operational Standards in CAI, 1982, 1st S.A. Congress on Computers in Education, Stellenbosch, 67-76.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink L. Glasser and G.C. Gerrans, Abstract 2.6: Progressive Development by CAI of Organic Structural Concepts, 1983, 7th Intl. Conf. Chem. Educ., Montpellier.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, CAI: A Report to the Academy, 1984, S.A.J. Sci., 80(1), 21-23.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, CBE in Southern Africa: A Unique Mix?, 1984, NECC '84, Dayton, Ohio, 155-159.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, Poster Presentation and Abstract: Chemical Formula Entry and Display in WITSCHEM, 1984, 25th Intl. ADCIS Conf., Columbus, Ohio, 254.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, Abstract: Project Report: WITSCHEM, 1984, 25th Intl. ADCIS Conf., Columbus, Ohio, 226.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink and L. Glasser, The Multi-Facetted Microcomputer: A Case Study of the Computer in an Educational Environment, 1985, Natl. Conf., The Computer in Education and Training, Computer Soc S.A., Pretoria.
J.D. Bradley, L. Glasser and S.W. Orchard, The Context of a CAI Lesson, 1986, 27th Intl. ADCIS Conf., New Orleans, LA, 180-183.
J.D. Bradley, G. Brink, L. Glasser and P. van Zyl, Set of six CAI programs in Chemistry: Coulomb's Law, Electrochemistry, Solubility Product, Nuclear Chemistry, Colligative Properties, Periodic Table Trends, J. Chem. Educ: Software, 1996, 73, 323; 1996, vol. 9B(1); 1997, Special Vol. 16 on CD-ROM; 1998, 2nd ed.
L. Glasser, Information Technology in Educational Science: Chemistry Teaching by Computer, 2000, S.A. J. Sci., 98, 155-9.

 


TopTopHeaderHeaderCEJv5n2CEJ Vol. 5, No. 2, Contents